Jane and the Stillroom Maid: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 5), by Stephanie Barron – A Review

Jane and the Stillroom Maid, by Stephanie Barron (2000)Touring the Derbyshire countryside in the summer of 1806, Jane Austen, her mother, sister Cassandra, and cousin Rev. Edward Cooper are staying at the Rutland Arms in Bakewell, in the Peak District. While on a day excursion out into the country with Mr. Cooper and his friend Mr. Hemming, the gentleman enjoy angling along the River Wye and Jane pursues her passion for a country walk, shortly ending in a disturbing discovery. A young gentleman is found “foully and cruelly” murdered on a crag near Millers’ Dale with a bullet in his head, his entrails torn from his body and his tongue cut out. Jane and Mr. Cooper are tourists to the area and the victim is unknown to them. Mr. Hemming, a local solicitor also claims not to recognize the young man. All three are deeply disturbed by the grisly discovery, but Mr. Hemming strangely acts out of character insisting that the body be transported a distance to Buxton and not to Bakewell the town under proper jurisdiction to the local Justice of the Peace and Coroner. After some uneasy discussion, Mr. Hemming reluctantly concedes to allow the corpse to be taken to Bakewell, but Jane cannot help but notice that he is acting like a man burdened with guilt.

The local surgeon Mr. Tivey is summoned from his blacksmith duties and examines the deceased. He recognizes the victim immediately, suspecting some kind of evil mischief afoot. The young gentleman is no gentleman, he is a lady, one Tess Arnold, the stillroom maid of Penfolds Hall, the country estate of Mr. Charles Danford near Tideswell, only one mile north of where the body was discovered. Tivey is quick to spread the shocking details among the villagers of the vicious extent of her wounds. He claims it is a ritual killing related to an act of revenge conducted by the Freemasons when one of their own is betrayed. The local Justice of the Peace, Sir James Villiers, arrives and interviews Jane and her cousin Mr. Cooper. The Coroner’s Inquest will be called in three days. Run by the disgruntled Mr. Tivey who has been very liberal with his derogatory opinions of the murder by the Freemasons after they rejected him as a member. The “evil weight of a jealous tongue” has turned the villagers into an angry mob who want justice. Sir James entreats Jane to remain in town and relay her story of discovering the mutilated corpse.

At the Coroner’s Inquest, the parties connected to the young victim Tess Arnold are called to be questioned. Jane and her cousin relay their story, but oddly, the third witness in the discovery, Mr. Hemming, does not appear when called. We learn more about the victim and her duties as stillroom maid, and, her disreputable character. Her former employer Charles Danforth, who is in mourning the recent death of his wife and child, recognizes the clothing found on the corpse as his own, but cannot explain how she had possession of them. His personal connection to the victim is scrutinized by the coroner and he storms out of the proceedings. The Housekeeper is questioned and reveals that Tess had been dismissed on the same day as her death. Feigning heart trouble, or is it purposeful swooning, the proceedings for the day are stopped to assist the housekeeper. As the inquest disperses, Sir James invites Jane for nucheon to discuss her opinions on the case and an old friend unexpectantly arrives.

At that moment, the rustling in the passage increased and the parlour door was thrust open. I turned, gazed, and rose immediately from my chair. A spare, tall figure, exquisitely dressed in the garb of a gentleman, was caught in a shaft of sunlight. He lifted his hat from his silver hair and bowed low over my hand

“It is a pleasure to see you again, Miss Austen. We have not met this age.”

Nor had we. But I must confess that the gentleman had lately been much in my thoughts.

“Lord Harold,” I replied a trifle unsteadily. “The honour is entirely mine.” Page 86

What a grand entrance for the Gentleman Rogue! Bathed in sunlight like a God? LOL! What? No twinkling stars in his eyes and blinding white teeth?

Jane and the Stillroom Maid is the fifth Jane Austen mystery, and for those unfamiliar with this series, the narrative is from a fictional diary written by Jane Austen and discovered in 1992 in a Georgian manor house near Baltimore. Inspired by actual events in Jane Austen’s life, historical facts and cultural detail, each of the novels has Jane Austen using her keen observational skills of human nature as a sleuth in a murder mystery.

This narrative is set in Pemberley country, that palatial country estate of Mr. Darcy, the hero of Austen’s famous novel Pride and Prejudice. Well, we don’t really know where in the county of Derbyshire the fictional Pemberley estate is, but we do have some clues from Austen that it was near Bakewell, where Jane and her family are staying in this story. It has long been suspected that Jane Austen modeled Pemberley after the famous Chatsworth House, the seat of the Duke of Devonshire, and the Cavendish family since 1549. It lies only three and a half miles from Bakewell. The fact that Lord Harold is a guest at Chatsworth and takes Jane there as his guest to be served ratafia, route cakes and rumors of indiscretions, that may of lead to murder, is a delicious coincidence. It is delightful to imagine that Jane Austen could have toured the Peak District in the summer of 1806 and visited Chatsworth and modeled her Pemberley after it.

Each of the chapters is prefaced by a recipe from the Stillroom Book of the victim Tess Arnold. Stillroom maids were a combination of herbalists, apothecary, and food preserver on large estates. Because of their skill at curatives and elixirs, stillroom maids were often accused of being witches, even in Jane’s time during the early 1800s. Some of the recipes are disturbing to modern sensibilities: adding brains of four cock sparrows or mourning doves into a fruit tart to give someone courage, ew! But the recipes added to the charm of the era and brought home how far we have evolved with modern medicine and education.

The mystery was intriguing, but I think I figured out the whodunit too soon. It did not spoil one moment of my enjoyment. Barron excels at historical detail, early 19th-century language, and fabulous characterization. Her portrayal of Jane Austen is so natural and engaging that I lose myself in the character and forget that this is just fiction. Jane’s friendship with Lord Harold is exciting and tragic. I want them to be a couple, but realize that his being the second son of a duke and she an impoverished gentleman’s daughter, that it cannot happen. I also enjoy finding allusions to Jane Austen’s own characters in Barron’s own and laughed-out-loud at her interpretation of Mr. Edward Cooper, Rector of Hamstall Ridware, Staffordshire, Jane’s first cousin, supercilious singing toad, and Mr. Collins knock-off. His reaction when being interrupted while fishing by Jane’s announcement of murder is hilarious:

“A corpse?” Mr. Cooper exclaimed, with a look of consternation. “Not again, Jane! However shall we explain this to my aunt?” page 31

5 out of 5 Regency Stars

Jane and the Stillroom Maid: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 5), by Stephanie Barron
Bantam Books (2000)
Mass market paperback (336) pages
ISBN:  978-0553578379

This is my fifth selection in the Being a Jane Austen Mystery Reading Challenge 2011. You can still join the reading challenge in progress until July 1, 2011. Participants, please leave comments and or place links to your reviews on the official reading challenge page by following this link.

Grand Giveaway

Author Stephanie Barron has generously offered a signed hardcover copy of Jane and the Stillroom Maid to one lucky winner. Leave a comment stating what intrigues you about this novel, or if you have read it, who your favorite character is by midnight PT, Wednesday, May 25, 2011. Winner to be announced on Thursday, May 26, 2011. Shipment to US and Canadian addresses only. Good luck!

© 2007 – 2011 Laurel Ann Nattress, Austenprose

25 thoughts on “Jane and the Stillroom Maid: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 5), by Stephanie Barron – A Review

Add yours

  1. A really well written review Laurel Ann. The book sounds like a HOOT!!!

    Here in England we get bottled mineral water from Buxton and a lovely cake from Bakewell called the Bakewell Tart.

    As for the Freemasons murdering somebody , they will never role up their trouser legs again. Ha! Ha!People would know who they were straight away. Obviously I haven’t read this yet, but knowing a little about the Freemasons, the character Sir James Villiers in his role as the Local Justice of the Peace, would probably have been the head of the local Freemasons.

    The next time they come round at Christmas dressed up as father Christmas’s and knock at my door collecting for local charities I’ll not think of them in the same way.

    Have a great day.



  2. The Stillroom Maid is possibly my favorite in the series. Full of smart intrigue with my, I mean Jane’s Gentleman Rogue… and anything set in Derbyshire and Chatsworth House –or any place really, that implies it may have been the inspiration for that magical place of Pemberley — always captures my interest. Page turner to the end! The interaction with the Freemasons and all the facts and innuendo — terribly fascinating. Great, great read!


  3. I’ve read the first four Jane mysteries and would love to have and read a signed copy of The Stillroom Maid! I am particularly excited and intrigued because it takes place in Derbyshire, one of my favorite spots on earth. I set part of my novel “The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen” (more at http://www.syriejames.com) in Derbyshire, and based Pembroke Hall in that book on Chatsworth House, which I visited at length and will never forget– what an amazing estate. To read Stephanie’s interpretation of Chatsworth would be thrilling. I love to read her books because they’re written from Jane’s POV, which makes them very dear to my heart.


  4. After reading this little teaser, I am anxious to read the book for myself to find out whodunit! This sounds like a very interesting book. I am also intrigued by the recipes to be found within!


  5. This is one of my favorites, with the medical aspect of the stillroom maid and Lord Harold, of course


  6. I’ve only read the first book in this series, and loved it. Have the next two to read, and need to add to the collection. I enjoy the book being written from Jane’s perspective.


  7. I haven’t read this book yet, but I am loving this series. My favorite character has to be the Gentleman Rogue! I love the relationship between Jane and Lord Harold!! Great review!!


  8. I haven’t read any of the books in the series yet, but have read positive reviews of all of them. This book sounds intriguing. Would love to read about the relationship between Jane and Lord Harold, and Mr. Hemming’s guilt. Thanks for the review!


  9. I haven’t read this latest book in the Jane mystery series, but love Stephanie’s books. This review has peaked by interest especially as it’s a “darker” mystery for our dear Jane. Thanks for the explanation of what is a stillroom maid.


  10. always one for a mystery! and none other than Jane could add this much to an intriguing story plus humour! thanks to Stephanie for your generosity and to you, Laurel Ann, for a great review :) happy to enter [and super glad my pc is finally running so that i CAN enter again] so sorry to have missed the others…


  11. I have read all the Jane Austen mysteries by Stephanie Barron with the exception Jane and the Madness of Lord Byron which is sitting on my shelf to be read soon. In Jane and the Stillroom Maid, I enjoyed Lord Harold Trowbridge — I think he’s a great match for dear Jane and very believable for a fictional character. I also love the connection to Chatsworth.


  12. My favorite character is Lady Harriet Cavendish. I like the insight that Hary-O provided as the daughter of Georgiana, Duchess of Devonshire. When I first read this book I had recently seen The Duchess and found Georgiana’s life fascinating. I wish Georgiana could have made an appearance in the book, but reading about her daughter and son as characters shed light on her life.


  13. I love this because it gives us a unique look at Jane Austen as a detective during her lifetime


  14. Having read ALL of the mysteries, I must say that this is not my favorite; possibly because of the “dark” element. Don’t get me wrong I liked the book (what’s not to like, it is Jane afterall), but the book moved at a slow pace and I was easily distracted from the book. I usually devour these precious novels and surprised even myself with how often I had to “go back” to this book.
    I loved the lake country setting and of course, the Gentleman Rogue’s return. One of my favorite elements of Stephanie’s mystery series, is the chapter heading intro. I love those little glimpses into Regency past or tidbits of info that is shared to enhance either the chapter or the story in general.
    Stephanie Barron has stirred a new level of love and appreciation in this Janeite.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: