Morning Light, by Abigail Reynolds – A Review

Morning Light, by Abigail Reynolds (2011)From the desk of Christina Boyd: 

Abigail Reynolds’ latest self-published offering, Morning Light, is all about second chances, (maybe even thirds). Escaping complicated city life, and all the muddled baggage that it entails, widow Annie Wright is finally living her dream of running her own art gallery on Cape Cod and free of any male persuasion.  The locals let her keep her past life private, especially the details of her famous husband’s death, and that is how she likes it.  Then one day, her past in the form of her dead husband’s college friend Jeremy, walks back into her present, setting Annie’s life into a whirlwind… or tailspin.

Annie first met Jeremy ten years prior on the eve of her wedding to Paul.  Even though they felt an instant, almost cosmic connection, once Jeremy realized who the bride was, they did NOT act on their feelings.  Rather than see Annie married to someone else, Jeremy left the country – and and walked out of her life.

Upon re-entry, Annie and Jeremy cannot but follow through on the inevitable, and a hot and heavy affair ensues.  Just when it seems their stars are lining up, Annie discovers a secret about Jeremy – and rather than confront him, she breaks off any contact – only to discover she has become pregnant.  Annie’s complications further increase as we are re-introduced to our hero and heroine from Book One in the Woods Hole series, The Man Who Loved Pride & Prejudice, Cassie and Calder Westing… and all the drama from their politically powerful family comes into play. (Regrettably as much as I lerved those characters in that first book, Calder seems to have been reduced to a rich Cape Cod hermit who wants nothing more from life than to be with his wife.

“Calder needed a lot of quiet time, and he was used to having his house to himself all day long.  He ended up hiding out in his study frequently.  He was accustomed to having Cassie to himself as well, and missed his time alone with her. (132)

But I digress…

Although it says right on the cover “inspired by Jane Austen’s Persuasion” – I believe it really has VERY LITTLE to do with Persuasion, its characters, or story.  Sure, second chance at love. But that’s it. However, Reynolds readily defends that it…

“started out in my mind as a Persuasion story, but I ended up having to make changes because certain parts of the story – most importantly why Anne rejects Frederick the first time – really don’t update well. I don’t see modern families persuading girls that their choice of a man is beneath them unless it’s about religion or race, and I didn’t want to touch either of those. So I moved the Persuasion theme to Annie’s family where her father insists on breaking off ties with her stepmother. Also it’s hard to write a modern Frederick who would just accept Anne’s dismissal without trying to argue her out of it; hence Annie’s marriage to prevent Jeremy from pursuing her.”

Further Reynolds believes she…

“…kept the Persuasion themes fairly well, like the changing ideal of the gentleman – Annie moves from being attracted to men with artistic talent and fame to choosing a man for his personality. The theme of the missing mother fit in easily with Annie’s mother and then stepmother disappearing, leaving her to raise herself. I worked in class consciousness through the Westing connection.”

Also, Reynolds explains that “most readers look for a plot replay, not a replay of themes,” so she originally thought not to market it as a Persuasion-related book. However, after writing eight Pride and Prejudice variations, and after receiving feedback from various cold readers, she worried that readers would assume this one would be as well. Hence the clarification on the cover art of “inspired by Jane Austen’s Persuasion.

Despite the questionable link to Persuasion (and Austen purist might easily argue that there isn’t one at all) Morning Light is still a page-turner that really deserves to stand on its own. It is this humble reviewer’s opinion and recommendation that readers discount the entire Persuasion reference, or better yet, ignore it all together. You will enjoy it so much more simply reading the story for what it is – a continuation of The Man Who Loved Pride and Prejudice (originally self-published as Pemberley by the Sea), and not confusing yourself by trying to connect the dots to Persuasion.  Chocked full of complex themes that rival any Nicholas Sparks novel, Morning Light has plenty of romance and steam for a sizzling, summer read.

4 out of 5 Stars

Morning Light, by Abigail Reynolds
Intertidal Press (2011)
Trade paperback (280) pages
ISBN: 978-0615471846

Cover image courtesy of Intertidal Press (2011); text Christina Boyd © 2011,

6 thoughts on “Morning Light, by Abigail Reynolds – A Review

Add yours

  1. So this is a great story, but with not as much Persuasion in it as hoped, eh? I can see where her inspiration started from though. Honestly, I am thrilled to see anything remotely connected to Persuasion. I think we are ready to move on to other story spinoffs than just P&P, and I think this is one of Austen’s most emotional and moving novels.

    I am happy to share that there are three Persuasion-inspired short stories in my upcoming anthology, Jane Austen Made Me Do It. :-)

    Thanks for another great review Christina. I know that you are very fond of Reynolds work and have read every one of her novels, so I value your judgement.

    Cheers, LA


  2. Thanks for reviewing it, Christina, and I’m glad you enjoyed it. I’d love to see more Persuasion books out there, too, but I think I’d go with a Regency if I tried to do it again. Fewer problems in translations that way.


  3. I’m intrigued — modern Persuasion stories that are faithful to the original plot points are almost has challenging as MP stories, and this one sounds like it captures the spirit of P if not the circumstances. I also love the Cape Code setting…one of my dream places.

    Sounds like a fun summer read.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: