The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen, by Syrie James – A Review

The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen, by Syrie James (2007)From the desk of Christina Boyd: 

Jane Austen. Fact: born December 16, 1775; died July 18, 1817 at age 41.  Fact:  never married. Fact: wrote six complete novels, including a few unfinished works, and juvenilia. Fact: lived out her life in a quiet Chawton Cottage with her older, spinster sister Cassandra and aging mother. Also known is that not long before her own death, Cassandra burned much of Jane’s private correspondence and even cut out entire passages of the letters saved, driving many discussions as to why? Many Jane Austen biographies abound and mention her brief flirtation with Tom Lefroy at the age of 19, and even her short-lived engagement to Harris Bigg-Wither, heir of Manydown Park, where over night she retracted her acceptance of his hand. But nothing from the author herself. Nothing as rich as a personal journal. What a literary triumph that would be to discover such a one!  Surely, a writer with transparent understanding of romance, great love and human nature would have had her own back story to mine such rich characters, conversations and scenarios as found in Pride & Prejudice, Persuasion, et al. Surely, such a mind would have experienced first-hand what it is to be in-love! Author Syrie James undertakes this venture of speculation in her novel, The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen.

In this fictional work, the story opens with an Editor’s Forward, written by a Mary I. Jesse, of Oxford University, President of the Jane Austen Literary Foundation, stating that manuscripts written in Jane Austen’s own hand were recently discovered in a chest that had been walled up at Chawton Manor House. These memoirs begin with Jane and Cassandra moving to Bath in 1801 with their parents, until Mr. Austen dies four years later, leaving the women barely solvent. During these years they make extended stays with their Austen brothers and are quite dependent on their kindness. On one particular occasion while visiting Lyme with her brother Henry, Jane meets the handsome, rich and amiable Mr. Frederick Ashford. As devoted Janeites will clearly perceive the language, phrasing and situations found in Austen’s masterpieces, we would also easily recognize many of her male protagonists’ characteristics in this fine gentleman. One example while strolling the Cobb, Jane loses her footing and would have fallen to her death on the hard pavement below if not for the quick actions by Mr. Ashford. A few moments later after this prophetic initial meeting, Jane attempts to properly thank him, Ashford declares

No thanks are necessary.’

‘Indeed they are.  Reaching out as you did, you might have lost your footing and come to harm yourself.’

‘Had that been the case, I would have given my life – or limb – in a worthy cause.’

‘Do you mean to imply that it was worth risking your life, to save mine?’

‘I do.’

‘A bold statement, on such a short acquaintance.’

‘In what way bold?’

‘You are a gentleman and the heir to a title and, apparently, a vast estate.  Whereas I am a woman with no fortune and of very little consequence.’

‘If first impressions are to be believed, Miss Austen’ he began.

‘Never trust your first impressions, Mr. Ashford.  They are invariably wrong.’

‘Mine are invariably right.  And they lead me to this conclusion: that you, Miss Austen, are a woman of greater fortune and consequence than I.’

‘On what grounds do you base this claim?’

‘On these grounds: if you were to have perished just now, how many people would have missed you?’

‘How many people?’


‘I would like to think my mother, my sister, my friend Martha, and my six brothers would miss me.  My brothers’ wives, my nieces and nephews, who number more than a dozen, and perhaps several dear old friends.’

‘Whereas I have only my friend and one younger sister to regret my passing.’

‘No wife, then?’

‘No.  So you see, although I may be rich in property, you are rich in family, and therefore the far more wealthy and important of us.’

I laughed.  ‘If wealth were based on your principle, Mr. Ashford, the entire class system of England would fall apart at the seams.’ Chapter 3

Although knowing from the beginning that this was entirely a tale of fancy, and knowing in my head that Jane never married, the story filled my heart with an impossible hope. Moreover, I was surprised when I found myself weeping when the happy event never came to be.

Syrie James has extensively researched Austen’s life and Regency times blending what we know as fact with the mysterious lore created by the gaps unknown to her public, creating a beautiful, fictional what if. The footnotes, maps and Austen family tree as well as the chronology of her life were delightful reference bonuses. Also included is a Q & A with the author, Quotations from Austen’s works and letters, and even Book Club/Reading Group Study Guide discussion points.

Although this novel is a work of fiction, I read it through wishing all along that it were not. Like many, I would like to imagine this brilliant, opinionated, witty woman had met the great love of her life and that she did in fact experience some of the magic she so keenly wrote of. Syrie James successfully creates a world of Jane Austen we can only wonder. “…but for my part, if a book is well written, I always find it too short.” (The Juvenilia of Jane Austen) With such sage words I can only echo that The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen is indeed entirely too short!

5 out of 5 Stars

The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen, by Syrie James
HarperCollins (2007)
Trade paperback (352)
ISBN: 978-0061341427

Cover image courtesy of HarperCollins © 2007; text Christina Boyd © 2010,

16 thoughts on “The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen, by Syrie James – A Review

Add yours

  1. Great review, esp the book snippet, my fave. I loved the “lost memoirs” book, just like LA, a part of me was wishing this was truly Jane’s unknown story. Loved Mr. Ashford’s character – gentle and yet interesting, esp with his engaging conversations with Jane, it was easy to imagine them as real! I loved the way how Ashford’s character was worked into Jane’s real life events, making the love story all to believable.


  2. This sounds delish — it’s a bit like reading Melanie Benjamin’s Alice I Have Been — I know she doesn’t marry her first love but when that scene rolled around, I was willing and praying for things to be different. I bet I’ll feel the same way about this! I need to start reading Ms James stat!


  3. This sounds very interesting! However, I don’t know that I would want to read this book for the same reason as your last few sentences state of regret that a marriage for Jane could never happen!

    I guess it’s the same reason I never watched Becoming Jane. :-/

    Lovely review, by the way.:)


    1. I think you should give it a try. It is satisfying what if despite what we know is truth. If you should give it a whirl, I would love to hear your thoughts on how much you did in fact like it! :)!!


      1. Hmmm…everyone seems to think it’s worth it…so, I’ll keep an eye out for the book. I don ‘t believe I have ever seen any Austen takes by other authors in our book stores!


  4. Great review Christina. I read this when it was first released in 2007, and it remains one of my favs. I really enjoyed Syrie James’ writing too. I’m glad you cried too! Now I do not feel like a hopelessly romantic Austen geek!!!


  5. I really did enjoy this book and glad you all liked the review– thanks for your kind comments. However, I am kicking myself for not having read it sooner. And to Laurel Ann, there is nothing wrong with being a hopelessly romantic Austen geek. Its a good thing! Merry- merry to one and all.


  6. I’ve eyed this with a great deal of trepidation, partly because I know the true end of the story, as you said, and partly because I was honestly afraid of the concept. It isn’t easy to write fiction that reads like it *could* have happened, when everyone knows it didn’t. After reading this review, I need to add this book to my (ever-growing) TBR pile.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: