Review by Shelley DeWees – The Uprising
“Accustomed as she was to the more retiring life on her father’s estate, Jane had not looked for any honors when she married Mr. Vincent. The few months of their marriage had been filled with work and the joy of learning to shape their lives together.”
It’s a sequel! To Shades of Milk and Honey! Are you excited? After the resounding success of that, Mary Robinette Kowal’s first book, you probably should be. But beware as you peruse this, gentle readers, for I have written it under the assumption that you’ve read and enjoyed the lovely first novel. Spoilers abound!
The end of Shades of Milk and Honey brought an explosive duel, the victory of a suitor, and, as all Regency-era novels tend to do, a wedding. Vincent and Jane are as happy as they’ve ever been, enjoying life not only as a romantic pair, gazing into each other’s eyes and invoking pet names at every opportunity, but also as a creative partnership. They effectively go into business together as England’s Best Glamourists and are swiftly snapped up by the Prince Regent and his cohort. Jane soon finds herself rubbing elbows with the aristocracy, and feels a certain apprehension at the new attention. Any mistake in her creations now affect her partnership, her place in the world…everything! Needless to say, she’s always the first one to leave the party and go upstairs.
Not that she’s unproductive. Much of the story is taken up by the discovery and implementation of Jane’s transport theories for magic, something she discovers by accident as she’s bouncing around Belgium on a working vacation/honeymoon. She explores, experiments, figures a few interesting things out…a few, uh, remarkable surprises. One is highly predictable. One is not. Another is utterly absurd. Blowing the cover on all of them now would be unkind, suffice to say that Jane’s life is again thrown into turmoil and she’s forced to call upon all her knowledge and expertise (and call in a few favors) to get everything to settle down again.
All of this is superimposed over Ms. Kowal’s elegant magic system, “glamour” as she calls it. Using the language of textiles, glamourists pull sheets and strands of glamour out of the “ether” and manipulate them in the way a master weaver would. Folding, braiding, knotting, and tying-off are all common acts with glamour, but it’s in the doing where creativity and deftness of hand where Jane really shines. She’s totally devoted to her craft, her confidence having grown exponentially as she took her first timid steps away from her father’s home. Yes, it’s a lovely arrangement, yet it still remains as mysterious and under-explained as it was in Shades of Milk and Honey. The only moderate salvation to the magic-curious people who take up Glamour in Glass is in a 2-page Glamour Glossary, tucked into the back of the book almost as an afterthought. Now, to be fair, Ms. Kowal does make the attempt to showcase the logistics of the magic with Jane’s stay at a school for glamourists, an innovative move but one that still left me guessing. For an author who’s so widely known for her fantasy and science fiction work, I’m still wishing for more! Certainly more than a glossary. Please?
But in general, the story bounds along in an elegant way. Kowal’s writing style is beautiful and engrossing, not to Regency-y but still conforming to the canon of the time. It’s a noble effort for a second novel, and displays a lot of growth and maturation for her second attempt. Her characters are still a little shallow, her pace a bit too quick, but a trip through Glamour in Glass shouldn’t leave you disappointed. If you enjoyed Shades of Milk and Honey, give this one a shot!
4.5 out of 5 Regency Stars
© 2007 – 2012 Shelley DeWees, Austenprose