Jane Austen Made Me Do It, edited by Laurel Ann Nattress – A Review

Jane Austen Made Me Do It , edited by Laurel Ann Nattress 2011From the desk of Christina Boyd: 

“It is only a novel… or, in short, some work in which the greatest powers of the mind are displayed, in which the most thorough knowledge of human nature, the happiest delineation of its varieties, the liveliest effusions of wit and humour are conveyed to the world in the best chosen language.”  Northanger Abbey, Volume 1, Chapter 5

Jane Austen Made Me Do It, Original Stories Inspired by Literature‘s Most Astute Observer of the Human Heart is a collection of twenty-two original Jane Austen-inspired stories including contributions from best-selling authors Pamela Aidan, Stephanie Barron, Carrie Bebris, Laurie Viera Rigler and Lauren Willig.  Editor Laurel Ann Nattress, and blog mistress of Austenprose – A Jane Austen Blog, has assembled her dream team of authors and for this anthology asking them to “stay within the theme of exploring Austen’s philosophies of life and love by reacquainting readers with characters from her novels or introducing original stories inspired by her ideals.  From historical to contemporary to young-adult fiction to paranormal, five of the major novels and Austen’s life are featured in this anthology,” p. xiv.  In addition, one story by a previously unpublished author, Brenna Aubrey, was picked as Grand Prize winner via a contest hosted by the Austen fan site Pemberley.com.  With such a significant range in this compilation, surely one would agree, “One cannot have too large a party.  A large party secures its own amusement.”  Emma, Volume 3, Chapter 6

On my first reading of this anthology, I must admit that I singled out my favorite authors first.  Yes, yes. I realize out of order was not how the editor intended it to be read, but, “One man’s way may be as good as anothers, but we all like our own best.”  Persuasion, Volume 2, Chapter 1.  So of course, for me, I began with “Jane & the Gentleman Rogue,” by Stephanie Barron. What can I say? You had me with the title. Anything that has more of the Gentleman Rogue must be 5 stars. This was a terrific “fragment of a Jane Austen Mystery” chocked full of treason and breathless intrigue, that Barron surely knocked out of the park!

Another stand out was “Letters to Lydia” by Maya Slater.  In the spirit of Jane Austen’s much studied remaining correspondence, these are letters from Pride and Prejudice’s minor character Maria Lucas, the younger sister of Mrs. William Collins, nee Miss Charlotte Lucas to Elizabeth Bennet’s youngest and wildest sister, Lydia Bennet. Loved, loved, loved how I could truly hear Maria’s voice as she recounts a supposed secret Love Affair and tryst between Fitzwilliam Darcy and Elizabeth Bennet– and how she unwittingly “helped them along.” (Bonus points for Mr. Collins’ lisp!)

“Jane Austen and the Mistletoe Kiss,” by Jo Beverley was a definite favorite. Flowing with Austen-like brilliance, this tale about a genteel, but impoverished, widow and her three daughters who have an amiable, rich neighbor who often meet was CHARMING from beginning to end.  Anytime there is a clear, happy ending, preferably resulting marriage, I am bound to be enchanted!

I was totally caught unawares by the cleverness in “What Would Austen Do?,” by Jane Rubino & Caitlen Rubino-Bradway.  A contemporary story about a teenage boy who inadvertently signs up for a Country Dance for Beginners class (and not the “Boot, Scoot, Boogie” kind of country dance!) and must learn how to make the most of this summer experience.  Fortunately, his keen wit and willingness to read Austen’s novels helps him  befriend the new girl in town.  Just loved! ALL OF IT! Fantastic– a teenage hero quoting Austen appropriately and with a terrific moral ending?  Even better, the authors biography states that they are currently developing “What Would Austen Do?” into a full length novel!

But, “All Merit you know is comparative,” Catharine.  In such a large collection of works there is bound to be a slight disappointment or two. While reading “Me and Mr. Darcy, Again,” a short extension of the novel, “Me and Mr. Darcy,” by Alexander Potter, I suffered not just a little discomfort with the idea that a now married Mr. Darcy is wandering outside heroine Emily’s hotel at night, staring up at her room, still carrying some sort of torch for her. In the end, Mr. Darcy does act honorably, and even charitably, in bringing about a happy resolution, but its conclusion was rather “vague.” But I liked the story, despite myself.  “A fondness for reading… must be an education in itself.” Mansfield Park, Volume 1, Chapter 2

I was somewhat under-whelmed by Pamela Aidan’s “The Riding Habit” as the now married Mr. Darcy seems to steam roll wife Elizabeth into riding, an activity she somewhat fears and takes no joy in. I also found it strangely odd that the pinnacle riding accident would bring about such a comparison to an upcoming ball and how she can surely expect the support of her loved ones around her.  Indeed?  Don’t get me wrong: Aiden’s writing style, language and cadence is pitch-perfect as ever.  Beautiful even. I simply found the story disjointed from the Darcy and Elizabeth she wrote so well of in her awe-inspiring, tremendously popular trilogy, Fitzwilliam Darcy, GentlemanHowever, “One half of the world cannot understand the pleasures of the other.”  Emma, Volume 1, Chapter 9

Still, there are a surfeit of solidly entertaining, easy to love stories.  Syrie James’ highly amusing “Jane Austen’s Nightmare” is just that!  While sleeping, our dear Jane is beset with characters from her novels, all with complaints on how she has represented their person. I particularly delighted in how the dream inspires her to write Persuasion.

One of the stories inspired by Persuasion is Margaret C. Sullivan‘s “Heard of You.”  I found this smart telling of how Admiral Croft and the former Miss Sophia Wentworth met as exciting at sea, as it was in the ballroom; making me sigh in all the right places!

“The Chase” by Carrie Bebris did not disappoint! Her depiction of a riveting and historic sea battle had me on the edge of my seat; truly captivated by this insight of how Jane Austen’s brother Frank became post-captain.

Laurie Viera Rigler offers the wickedly satirical and campy “Intolerable Stupidity” that imagines a courtroom drama where Mr. Darcy sues authors of Pride and Prejudice spin-offs for how they have sketched his character.  Of course, the honorable Lady Catherine de Bourgh presides!

The anthology opens with an introduction by the editor, Laurel Ann Nattress, as she pays deference to Jane Austen as well as the many novels, sub-genre and films Austen has inspired.  Nattress shares how she came to love Austen’s work in the ‘80s and how Austen has since catapulted to “megastar status” by means of “her strongest catalyst: the Internet and a wet shirt.” p. xii.  Also, I took particular delight in the Readers Guide where the 22 contributing authors selected their favorite Austen quote. It was as if taking a stroll down memory lane with a dear friend. Reading groups and book clubs will find the Questions and Topics for Discussion pages beneficial.

The Austen Legacy continues to grow and this collection of wonderful short stories is a brilliant tribute.  Janeites and historical fiction readers alike will inhale this book!  But with a dream team of Austen inspired writers under the deft editing skills of Laurel Ann Nattress, how could this be anything but a grand slam!  “The person, be it gentleman or lady, who has not pleasure in a good novel, must be intolerably stupid.”  Northanger Abbey, Volume 1, Chapter 14

Authors included: Lauren Willig • Adriana Trigiani • Jo Beverley • Alexandra Potter • Laurie Viera Rigler • Frank Delaney & Diane Meier • Syrie James • Stephanie Barron • Amanda Grange • Pamela Aidan • Elizabeth Aston • Carrie Bebris • Diana Birchall • Monica Fairview • Janet Mullany • Jane Odiwe • Beth Pattillo • Myretta Robens • Jane Rubino and Caitlen Rubino-Bradway • Maya Slater • Margaret C. Sullivan • and Brenna Aubrey, the winner of a story contest hosted by the Republic of Pemberley

5 out of 5 Stars

Jane Austen Made Me Do It: Original Stories Inspired by Literature’s Most Astute Observer of the Human Heart, edited by Laurel Ann Nattress
Ballantine Books (2011)
Trade paperback (446) pages
ISBN: 978-0345524966

Cover image courtesy of Ballantine Books © 2011, text Christina Boyd © 2011, Austenprose.com

29 thoughts on “Jane Austen Made Me Do It, edited by Laurel Ann Nattress – A Review

Add yours

  1. Thanks for the review- just got my copy in the mail yesterday and am even more excited to read it now. :)

    One criticism- ‘Jane Austen and the Mistletoe Kiss…tale about a gentile…’ I think you meant genteel. A gentile is a non-Jewish person, but the word is commonly misused on fan-fiction sites (and drives me mad…) LOL


    1. Oh of course I would have a glaring typo on this particular review. How embarrassing! Thanks for the catch and I am sure when LaurelAnn returns from the JASNA AGM in Ft Worth she will correct it for me. Thanks again. Enjoy!


  2. Thank you for your break-down of different author’s pieces in the anthology. It is always interesting to see how other people think about things.
    I eagerly await my own turn at reading this book of stories.
    Thanks for posting!


  3. Hi Laurel Ann and Christina: Your publicity tour is working. My Aunt from British Columbia B.C. emailed me and asked if I had heard of you and your book. The jungle drums are in full force. Can’t wait to read your anthology.


  4. I might add that I wrote this review from my advanced copy, missing the story of contest winner, Brenna Aubrey. Upon reading my complete copy on Thursday, I found Aubrey’s Persuasion inspired contemporary story, written from a male doctor’s point of view, quite lovely. That contest certainly discovered a talented writer.
    There is also the additon of discussion questions — perfect for book clubs. I also enjoyed the additon of the anthology’s contributing authors’ favorite Austen quotes… Much like a stroll down memory lane with a comfortable friend.
    What I like so much about short story anthologies is that regardless of your schedule, you can usually find time to read at least one story… the tricky part is having the will power to not read the whole thing in one sitting! Enjoy!


  5. I do agree with your thoughts on “Me and Mr. Darcy, Again” though I do think it makes more sense in the larger context if you’ve previously read “Me and Mr. Darcy.” I do really like how Laurel Ann opened and closed the collection – it made it feel like I had come full circle in a way.


  6. Christina, by the end of your review I find that I must immediately type in the title and order it!
    I suspect that there will be as much enjoyment in reading it again, after I have read all the stories!
    I love Stephanie’s comment: “I opened at Lauren Willig’s hilarious Northanger take-off, and immediately wanted it to be a book…!” This has to be the ultimate compliment to any author of a short story!
    Thank you, one and all!


  7. I was likewise caught unawares by the ability of the authors of “Lady Vernon and Her Daughter”, arguably the most authentic adaptation of an Austen work (confession – saw the two ladies talk at the Morgan in NYC in 2010 – totally captivated) to shift gears to a young adult tale. James Austen was a delight and the use of language was funny and clever.
    Yes, anthologies can be a mixed bag and I am among those who is starting to turn off to a tale with “Mr. Darcy” in the title. If there is a follow up book, perhaps you would invite Eucharista Ward who penned the delightful “A Match for Mary Bennet.”


  8. Well Christina, you really got the PLUM to pick as far reviews go! On the other hand, reviewing an anthology instead of a single work had to be challenging and your review is so very enticing/inviting. (not that this collection needed any further momentum) My favorite contributing author? Lauren Willig: I’m in love with EVERYTHING you ever wrote or plan to write. Am I planning to read this? Do ya think? DO YA THINK ?? A deserving review of a deserving project.


  9. Just wanted to add that as the parent of two teenaged boys, I got a huge kick out of Jane Rubino and Caitlen Rubino-Bradway’s contribution, “What Would Jane Do?” and am so looking forward to the book-length version they’re currently developing.


  10. What, were we supposed to read these authors in sequence presented? Surely not! Be like getting a box of mixed chocolates and eating from left to right in order arranged.
    I will admit that after reading this review, I must place Alexander Potter’s last, so much do I agree with your disinclination to think of Mr Darcy losing his obsession
    with Elizabeth. I might have to skip that one, thanks for the warning.
    I’m about halfway through now, and loving all of this collection, so far. Thank you Laurel Ann


    1. No, no– don’t skip it. I liked it well enough and it all ends well. It just made me a bit uncomfortable — even though I have read the novel “Me and Mr Darcy” and understand the history there. I’d be interested to know what you thought after reading it.


  11. My plan was to be at the book signing at Ft. Worth to meet you and get my signed copy. That was before I missed my flight, got there at 11pm, and then got sick and missed the entire AGM. My consolation was that somehow I was going to make it to the Barnes and Noble round the corner from the hotel to pick it up for the trip home. Couldn’t make it happen. Tomorrow I will absolutely go pick it up and I can’t wait to get it!


  12. My only problem is that I finished it before the end of my flight home! I, too loved “What Would Jane Do?” (about the teenaged boy) and “The Love Letter” by the previously unpublished Brenna Aubrey (especially the very clever final line, “Jane Austen made me do it.” Perfectly framed by its context. Loved all the stories, really.

    Enjoyed seeing you, LA.


  13. I was so taken with ‘What Would Austen Do?’ – there had to be a ROTFL line on every page. The Lady Catherine and Elton remarks and some of the terms they used like ‘that creet Mr. Collins’ cracked me up. I have not gone through every story yet but so far WWAD was my favorite with STephanie Barrons, Carrie Bebris,Amanda Grange and Margaret Sullivan close seconds.


  14. No secret that i am a big fan of Rubino as well as ‘Lady Vernon and Her Daughter’ so i knew that Rubino could ‘change course’ (she wrote a mystery series set in present day NJ) but What Would Austen Do? still surprised me. I liked the way thte story unfolded with poor James in the principals office and then the back story to how he wound up there and what Jane Austen had to do with it – and just loved the use of language!
    I was also taken with Carrie Bebris story because it was so different from all of the others. It is the other one that i thought would make an interesting book as well as Stephanie Barrons because i really enjoy her Jane Austen mystery series.


  15. Got my book today from Laurel Ann at the Alderwood Mall B&N and I’m thrilled. I can hardly wait to read it. Great review by the way.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: