Jane and the Genius of the Place: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 4), by Stephanie Barron – A Review

Jane and the Genius of the Place: Being the Fourth Jane Austen Mystery, by Stephanie Barron (1999)In the summer of 1805, we find Jane Austen visiting her wealthy brother Edward and his large family at their palatial country estate Godmersham Park in Kent, enjoying the comforts of living above “vulgar economy,” and the privileges of ease and splendor. Her father Rev. Austen had passed away the following January, displacing herself, her sister Cassandra and their mother from their rented residence in Bath. This was the beginning of their wilderness years when the Austen women would shuffle about from relative to relative, homeless genteel vagabonds, dependent on the generosity of their families for a roof over their heads. While Jane visits in Kent, her sister Cassandra resides nearby at Goodnestone with Mrs. Bridges, the mother of Edward’s wife Elizabeth, and Mrs. Austen is in Hampshire.

Jane wastes no time in enjoying their opulent society with an outing to the Canterbury Races to picnic on the green and watch her brother Henry’s latest folly with the Sporting Set, his magnificent racehorse Commodore, who is set to take his paces against the local favorites. Among the festivities, it is hard not to notice a beautiful young woman in a scarlet riding costume sitting in a phaeton near their own carriage. As she lashes out injuring a young man with her driving whip, Jane is shocked by her wild behavior. Her sister-in-law Elizabeth Austen explains that she is the notorious Francoise Lamartine Grey, the spirited young wife of a wealthy local banker who owns the grand neighboring estate The Larches. Besides being a Frenchwomen in England during the height of the “Great Terror,” when many feared Bonaparte’s invasion of the English coast, she is disliked by everyone in the neighborhood because of scandalous behavior. While Henry’s horse loses the race, Mrs. Grey loses her life.

Brutally strangled by her hair ribbon and stripped of her red riding costume, she is found in the carriage of her former lover Denys Collingworth, a man of “slim means, illiberal temper and general disfavor of the whole neighborhood.” As the local Justice of the Peace, Edward Austen steps forward and takes command of the investigation, aided by the observant eyes of his sister Jane, his wife Elizabeth, and their governess Anne Sharpe, they are able to recount the events of the day involving Mrs. Grey’s movements. But something is awry. How could she lie dead in the carriage and then later be seen on horseback recklessly jumping the racecourse rail, chasing after the galloping horses, collecting the winner’s cup, and then promptly departing in her phaeton? All eyes are on Collingworth who feigns absence corroborated by a witness. He points the finger at family friend Captain Woodford and Elizabeth Austen’s brother Rev. Edward Bridges who are both deeply in debt to Mrs. Grey. Later we learn that her husband does not mourn Francoise’s death, nor does he attend her funeral. As the suspects add up, Edward and Jane are uncertain that what appears to be a lovers quarrel gone terribly wrong, in fact, involves international espionage and Bonaparte’s far-reaching ambitions.

Jane and the Genius of the Place is the fourth Being a Jane Austen Mystery, by Stephanie Barron, the very popular series involving British novelist Jane Austen as an amateur sleuth paralleling actual events from her own life. It is told in a first-person narrative from Jane’s perspective edited from her personal journals discovered by the author in an outbuilding on an ancient Maryland estate. They blend the factual and the fictional, incorporating known events and facts from Austen’s letters, history, culture, and politics with a clever mystery story. This is my fourth of the series and I found it fascinating. The storyline introduces many of the social pursuits that a Regency gentleman would aspire to: horse racing, “improvement of the estate,” cultivation of the manor house and family. In addition to the return of Jane’s favorite brother Henry Austen, we are introduced to her elder brother Edward, his wife Elizabeth, daughter Fanny and the brood of their other eight children. Governess to the two daughters is Anne Sharpe, with whom Jane will develop a lifelong friendship. Barron did a superb job with Elizabeth “Lizzy” Austen as a companion and sounding board to Jane and the investigation. Elegant, intelligent, and composed, Lizzy is the kind of mother, sister-in-law, or friend that we all should have in our lives, but rarely do. It is understandable how her death in 1808 was such a shock to Jane and her family.

I loved the introduction of the Austen’s governess Anne Sharpe, who we know little about other than a few surviving letters, and that Jane valued her friendship enough to give her a presentation copy of Emma when it was published in 1815. In this story, she has a flirtation of such with landscape designer Julian Southey, which I wish had been played out more. The aesthetic movement of the “improvement of the estate” is woven into the plot in detail, and as a landscape designer myself for many years, I appreciated the beautiful descriptions of the transformation of the English countryside into the picturesque visions made popular by designers Humphrey Repton and Capability Brown.

Even though Jane Austen is criticized for not broaching politics in her novels, she did talk about them in her letters and followed the Napoleonic Wars through her two brothers in the Royal Naval. Politics, international espionage, and French spies factor heavily into this novel in a clever way. In addition, with the introduction of new characters, I did not miss the lack of Cassandra Austen, who seems to be a killjoy in the series, nor Mrs. Austen who is a bit of a downer for “our” Jane. Even though the mystery drove the plot, I found myself guessing whodunit early on. It really didn’t matter in the least. The writing is so entrancing, the descriptions so mesmerizing and the characters so enjoyable, that nothing was wanting – well, except the shortage of Lord Harold Trowbridge, Rogue, Flirt, and personal Infatuation. I impatiently await his return.

5 out of 5 Stars

Jane and the Genius of the Place: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 4), by Stephanie Barron
Bantam Books (2000)
Mass market paperback (384) pages
ISBN: 978-0553578393


Author Stephanie Barron has generously offered a signed hardcover copy of Jane and the Genius of the Place to one lucky winner. Leave a comment stating what intrigues you about this novel, or if you have read it, who your favorite character is by midnight PT, Wednesday, April 27, 2011. Winner to be announced on Thursday, April 28, 2011. Shipment to US and Canadian addresses only. Good luck!

© 2007 – 2011 Laurel Ann Nattress, Austenprose

26 thoughts on “Jane and the Genius of the Place: Being a Jane Austen Mystery (Book 4), by Stephanie Barron – A Review

Add yours

  1. I liked this one too– but agree, not enough Gentleman Rogue. Still I liked the story being at her brother Edward’s estate and seeing the mystery unfold there. Seriously, not a clue to the real villain until it was revealed. Page turner indeed.
    (May I be the first to solicit a series from Stephanie Barron where she sifts through his papers and writes the memoirs that Jane was unable to do???!!)


  2. Elizabeth Austen is my favorite character in this story. I agree with Laurel Ann that the author did a wonderful job in her depiction of Elizabeth’s personality. I wish she could have appeared in some of the later books in the series.


  3. I’ve read a few of the books in this series but not in order. It would be great to fill in the blanks especially about Elizabeth since she was talked about in Jane and the Madness of Lord Byron which I read last month!


  4. I loved this book; I listened to it while away on a business trip. I agree with the others that Elizabeth Austen was a favorite. I’ve recommended Stephanie’s books to several of my friends.


  5. This series is SO fantastic! I love how Stephanie Barron ties in things of historical interest with the Austen family. Lord Harold Trowbridge is hands down the best character in these books, after dear Jane, of course. This one wasn’t one of my favorite mysteries, but there hasn’t been a book in the series that I have *disliked*.


  6. I loved this book! I’m doing the challenge and am reading these in order and prior to your reviews of them. I liked the way Elizabeth Knight is portrayed but I know it has been speculated that she didn’t really like Jane Austen. That niggled at me while I read the book. I didn’t peg the villain for sure until it was revealed at the end. On to the next book!


  7. I’ve only read the first book in this series, and loved it so much I rushed out to buy the second and third books! Thanks for the opportunity to win the fourth, to continue the fun!


  8. Just wanted to add that the forthcoming (and probably final) Jane Austen mystery, Jane and the Canterbury Tale, is also set at Godmersham–after Elizabeth Austen’s death, in 1813, and it revisits a number of these characters. Fanny, for example, is twenty in the next book; and Edward still haunted by his love for his lost wife. For more on the improvement of the estate and landscape gardening, do stop by my blog at http://www.stephaniebarron.com . Thanks, all!


      1. This would be very sad indeed. This is one of my favorite series, and I always look forward to the release of the latest book. All good things must come to an end though, and hopefully Stephanie will continue to release other great books!


  9. I have not read this book yet, but I can’t wait to do so! This story sounds wonderful! Thank you so much for hosting this challenge. I don’t know if I would have tried these books if you didn’t and I am loving them!!


  10. I’m finishing up the first book in the series and I am totally in love with it. I already went out and bought the second and third books before I was even halfway through the first one. :) Jane and the Genius of the Place sounds equally wonderful, and I would love to win a copy! Thanks for hosting this challenge – I’ve been meaning to pick up the series for practically forever and now that I finally have, I am really loving it.


  11. Ooh, the fact that Anne Sharpe is in this one is very intriguing to me. I find her fascinating. Looking forward to reading this one.


  12. My favorite character from this book is Anne Sharpe, the governess to Edward and Elizabeth’s children. Stephanie Barron does a great job of showing how Jane would have compared her situation to Anne’s and how fortunate Jane and Cassandra felt to be supported by their brothers.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: