Jane Eyre 2011: A Film Review by Syrie James

Jane Eyre (2011) movie posterInquiring Readers: We are very fortunate to welcome author, screenwriter and Janeite Syrie James for a guest film review today. She recently attended an advance screening of the new movie adaptation of Charlotte Brontë’s classic Gothic romance Jane Eyre which premieres in limited release today in the US.

Welcome Syrie – and thanks for the timely review!

Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre has been my favorite book since I was 11 years old. I’ve read it so many times I’ve lost count. The tale of a feisty governess who finds true love in a spooky mansion, while pouring her heart out on the page in lush, romantic prose, has made it to the top of every “Best Love Stories” list since it was first published in 1847, and with good reason.

Michael Fassbender and Mia Wasikowska in Jane Eyre (2011)The perfect Gothic novel, Jane Eyre melds all the requisite elements of mystery, horror, and the classic medieval castle setting with heart-stopping romance. The story is also very appealing: the rise of a poor orphan girl against seemingly insurmountable odds, whose love and determination ultimately redeem a tormented hero. And the book has serious things to say about issues that are still relevant today: women’s struggle for equality, the realization of self, and the nature of true love. The novel appeals not only to an audience’s hearts, but also to their heads.

Of all the classic 19th-century novels, Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre has been by far the most filmed, with at least 18 film versions (including a 1910 silent movie) and 9 made-for-television movies.

The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Bronte, by Syrie James (2009)I have seen nearly all of them—some multiple times—both out of my deep love for the tale, and as part of the research for my novel The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë, the true story of Charlotte’s remarkable life, her inspiration behind “Jane Eyre,” her rise to fame as an author, and the little-known story of her turbulent, real-life romance. (My novel was named a Great Group read by the Women’s National Book Association, and the audio book version was just nominated for an Audie Award, the Oscars of the audiobook publishing world—very exciting!)

Every screen version of JANE EYRE has its merits, and it’s always a thrill to re-experience my favorite, beloved scenes from the book with each new adaptation. I especially loved Timothy Dalton’s portrayal of Mr. Rochester in the 1983 mini-series, and the 2006 Masterpiece Theatre mini-series starring Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens.

I was very curious to see how the new JANE EYRE adaptation from Focus Films would measure up. I am happy to report that the film, which I saw Monday night at an advance screening, is very good indeed, with marvelous visuals, terrific performances, and enough unique elements to make it a worthy new addition.

The most notable distinction of this film that sets it apart from the rest is its structure. Rather than telling the tale in a straight-forward, linear fashion, it begins at a crisis moment that occurs later in the story, and tells the majority of the tale in flashback–similar to the structure of The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë–and it works wonderfully well here, enabling screenwriter Moira Buffini to effectively compress a long novel into a two-hour time span.

Jane Eyre (Mia Wasikowska) on the Moors in Jane Eyre (2011)The movie opens as Jane is fleeing Thornfield after having discovered Mr. Rochester’s dark and heartbreaking secret. We fear for her as she becomes lost on the stormy moor. The mystery continues as St. John Rivers (well-played by a sympathetic yet appropriately stern Jamie Bell) and his sisters take her in. Who is this lost lamb? Why does she call herself Jane Elliott? Who or what is she running from? As Jane ruminates about the past events that led to her escape, we are treated to the story in flashback.

The casting of Mia Wasikowska (Alice in Tim Burton’s ALICE IN WONDERLAND) as Jane Eyre also sets this production apart, since she is closer in age than most actresses who’ve played the role to the character in the novel, who was about 18 years old in the Thornfield section. Although I wish Mia’s Jane was a bit more “swoony” over Mr. Rochester earlier on (yes, she is supposed to be stoic, but I missed that phase where we get to see her blossom as she falls in love with him, and then is utterly crushed when she believes him to be in love with Miss Ingram), Mia truly inhabits the role, beautifully portraying Jane’s sense of self-respect, integrity, and restraint, as well as her passion and vulnerability.

Mr. Rochester (Michael Fassbender) in Jane Eyre (2011)Michael Fassbender was also inspired casting. He embodies Mr. Rochester with the ideal blend of charisma and sinister brooding, while at the same time allowing glimpses of his underlying desperation and the wounded depths of his soul. When Jane and Rochester finally admit their love for each other, it is romantic and exciting, with sparks flying. (As this is my favorite part of the story, for me it was also far too short!)

Sally Hawkins as Mrs. Reed, adorned in stiff ringlets and satin gowns, effectively portrays the icy ogre who menaces the young Jane (a spirited and appealing Amelia Clarkson.)

Mrs. Fairfax (Judi Dench) and Jane Eyre (Mia Wasikowska ) in Jane Eyre (2011)And how can you go wrong with Judi Dench as housekeeper Mrs. Fairfax? As always, Dench gives a rock-solid performance, with subtle nuances that make the role her own.

The film’s locations do justice to the novel’s often gloomy, atmospheric tone. Haddon Hall in Bakewell, Derbyshire, built atop a limestone outcropping and one of the oldest houses in England, stands in for Thornfield Hall. According to location manager Giles Edleston, Haddon Hall has “more rooms and sets than a filmmaker could ever wish for,” and Director Cary Fukunaga makes terrific use of it, emphasizing its dark, Gothic, masculine feel, especially effective in a particular, chilling attic scene.

The exterior locations—gardens, cliffs, craggy rocks, stone walls, and seemingly endless fields—make an arresting, dramatic backdrop for the story. The press notes state, “Although we made it seem like Thornfield is in the middle of nowhere, just beyond the edge of the frame was modern civilization.” Rest assured that the illusion is complete; you truly do feel as though you are in the middle of nowhere.

Rochester (Michael Fassbender) and Jane (Mia Wasikowska) in Jane Eyre (2011)

The film also effectively makes use of the top of the gardens surrounding Derbyshire’s Chatsworth House—a location more commonly associated with Austen’s Pride and Prejudice—to film Jane Eyre’s dramatic first encounter with Mr. Rochester, when he appears out of the mist and fog astride his horse.

I have only two minor gripes with the film (WARNING: minor spoiler alert. If you aren’t familiar with the classic story, you might want to stop reading now.) While the revelation of Mr. Rochester’s secret was very well-done, I felt it was a little too “prettified.” And the ending was too abrupt for me. An explanation (for the uninitiated) of Rochester’s condition in the final scene would have been nice, and I would have preferred another minute or two to relish the lovers’ emotional reunion. But that aside, the filmmakers have done a masterful job translating the novel to the screen.

Please share your thoughts and comments about Jane Eyre. When did you first read the novel? Which film adaptations are your favorites, and why? If you’ve read The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë, did it enhance your appreciation of Jane Eyre?

You can learn more about the new film at the Jane Eyre facebook page, where there’s a trailer and a “Jane Eyre Challenge” with a kindle as a prize. The movie opens today, March 11. I highly recommend it! Go see it soon at a theater near you!


Syrie James, hailed as the “queen of nineteenth century re-imaginings” by Los Angeles Magazine, is the bestselling author of four critically acclaimed novels: The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen (Best First Novel 2008, Library Journal), The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë (Audie-nominated, Great Group Read, Women’s National Book Association), Dracula, My Love (which reveals Mina Harker’s passionate love affair with the most famous vampire of them all), and most recently Nocturne, praised by Library Journal as “lyrical, lush, and intensely romantic.” The translation rights for Syrie’s books have been sold in fifteen languages. Her short story “Jane Austen’s Nightmare” will appear in Laurel Ann Nattress’s Austen anthology Jane Austen Made Me Do It, due out from Ballantine Books in October.  Syrie’s next novel, Forbidden, which she co-wrote with her son Ryan, will be published by HarperTeen in early 2012.

A member of the Writer’s Guild of America, RWA, and a lifetime member of the Jane Austen Society of North America, Syrie is an admitted Anglophile and is obsessed with all things Austen, although she lives in Los Angeles. For more information about Syrie’s books, please visit www.syriejames.com. Syrie also invites you to friend her on facebook (and leave a comment!) and follow her on Twitter @SyrieJames.

Further reading:

© 2007 – 2011 Syrie James, Austenprose

21 thoughts on “Jane Eyre 2011: A Film Review by Syrie James

Add yours

  1. Thank you Syrie for the review! I am looking forward to seeing Jane Eyre on the big screen. This may, almost, make up for missing P & P when it came to theaters.


  2. Ms. James review has made me doubly eager to watch this adaptation! The cinematography sounds sumptuous (and sufficiently gothic) from your description. Fukunaga said in an interview that the Orson Welles version made quite an impact on him as a child, so I expect the gothic elements to come to the fore… =)


  3. What a thoughtful review – this just makes me want to see the movie even more! I am huge Michael Fassbender fan, so I would watch it even if it were bad, just for him, but I’m happy that you liked him in the role. It is, however, going to be hard for him to beat out Toby Stephens in my opinion. As much as I love Michael, Toby was masterful in the Jane Eyre mini-series.


  4. Thanks for the wonderful review…I have linked it along with my “Jane Eyre 2011” Movie Prize Pack Giveaway I have going on at Stiletto Storytime hosted by Focus Features. I know my readers will love your insights just as much as I do. Thanks again to Syrie James and Laurel Ann for making this happen!

    P.S. I cannot wait to see the movie…


  5. The most notable distinction of this film that sets it apart from the rest is its structure. Rather than telling the tale in a straight-forward, linear fashion, it begins at a crisis moment that occurs later in the story, and tells the majority of the tale in flashback–similar to the structure of The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Brontë–and it works wonderfully well here, enabling screenwriter Moira Buffini to effectively compress a long novel into a two-hour time span.

    This reminds me of a certain sequence in the 2006 miniseries. Once Jane learned of Rochester’s secret, we see her fleeing Thornfield Hall. Once she reached the safety of the Rivers household, the miniseries featured flashbacks of Rochester trying to seduce Jane into remaining at Thornfield.


  6. Thanks, Syrie, for the comprehensive review. Jane Eyre has been one of my favorite classics for as long as I can remember and I love all of the film adaptations. I can see I need to go see this one right away! Cheers! BCC


  7. Can’t wait till this comes to Toronto next weekend. I just re-watched the 2006 version with Ruth Wilson and Toby Stephens last night. I love a good cry!

    Anyone who wants to see my photos of my afternoon at Haddon Hall in Derbyshire where this was filmed is welcome to my blog at:


    It’s a magical place and it really IS Thornfield Hall!

    Thanks for the great post Syrie! Now I want to read your book.


  8. I finally, FINALLY got to see this movie yesterday (review posted today) and I absolutely LOVED IT. Now the only question is, how long I can wait before seeing it again. :)


  9. Same as Syrie, Jane Eyre has been my favorite book since my adolescent years. I grew up in a Spanish country and Jane Eyre was a mandatory reading as part of my English class. It swept me away. Since then, I have read it so many times that I can’t even give you an estimate number. I have tried to see as many versions as possible. And, my favorite versions are still the one with Timothy Dalton as Rochester (mesmerizing) and the one with Orson Wells as Rochester.

    I hate to say… I did not like this last version. I left the theater disappointed and a little angry. And I was not the only one…
    The abrupt ending, the lack of explanation of why is Rochester the way he is at the end. The cinematography is beautiful, the landscape and Thornfield Hall is just like you imagine when you read the book but I felt something missing and that was the repressed passion that you feel when you read the book. I felt the movie was done in rush. Even my husband asked “¿Do you think that the script writer and the director read the book?”

    I hope that you all enjoy this version of the movie and that these feeling are just mine. But this is not the Jane Eyre I read and it is not what I was expecting.


  10. Just wanted to comment that I am 64 yrs of age and have just completed reading my Kindle version of Jane Eyre. I LOVED it. What a wonderful experience it was to read this and join Jane on her journey of life with all the twists and turns, ups and downs! I got very involved in the story, when it was cold and damp in the story, I felt cold and damp. When it was springtime weather, I felt the sun, I heard the birds.When she left Mr Rochester and was living outdoors for a few days before she met the Rivers family and was starving to death, I actually felt so hungry at that point in the story! I dont remember ever in my life ever getting so involved in the main character!
    I went through all her emotions while reading the book, and when I wasnt reading it, I was in wonder of what I would do if it were me, if I would handle things as well as Jane did, if I as a Christian would live up to my beliefs as well as she did, and would just think about it all the time. I would feel anticipation at times when I had to go about my life and duties and couldnt get to continue for a day or two! This book is now one of my all time favorites. I highly recommend reading this story when you wont have too many interruptions in life…it is such a good read.


  11. The highlights of the book are in the film but what makes Jane Eyre a great story and her a great character doesn’t come across. People who haven’t read the book won’t see what all the fuss is about; people who have (like me) will make a fuss about what isn’t there.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: