Darcy and Anne, by Judith Brocklehurst – A Review

Darcy and Anne, by Judith Brocklehurst (2009)Originally self-published in 2007 as A Letter to Lady Catherine, this Pride and Prejudice spinoff has a surprising new heroine – Anne De Bourgh! Yes, I heard that collective gasp of astonishment. A whole novel devoted to Mr. Darcy’s sickly, unaccomplished, and henpecked cousin? Indeed! Judith Brocklehurst’s novel may have been given a grand makeover with a new title and prettyish new cover by its publisher Sourcebooks, but can its heroine also be transformed from a minor but memorable character in the original novel, into a heroine that readers can identify with and admire?

Destined from the cradle to be Mr. Darcy’s bride, Anne De Bourgh and her domineering mother Lady Catherine never expected any other outcome than the union of two sisters great families: the De Bourgh’s and the Darcy’s. When Mr. Darcy chooses Elizabeth Bennet, a young woman of inferior birth and no importance instead of her daughter Anne, Lady Catherine vows never to speak to her nephew again. Bored with her daughter’s company, Lady Catherine is determined to find her a husband calling upon all her social connections to introduce her to an eligible bachelor of either noble rank or equal fortune. Even though Anne has a handsome dowry of £30,000, the combination of officious Lady Catherine as a mother-in-law and the unattractive and sickly Anne as a wife sends prospective beaux’s running. After two years and all of the possible alliances with local families have been exhausted, Lady Catherine does the unthinkable. She writes to her nephew and offers a truce, invites herself to Pemberley, and insists that since he has placed her and her daughter in this untenable situation by marrying another, that it is his duty to find Anne a husband.

Dreading this new scheme, Anne and her mother depart for Pemberley – and then – provenance steps in. Along the road, Lady Catherine is injured and Anne must rely upon the kindness of a stranger Mrs. Endicott to assist her in finding a doctor for her mother and shelter in Burley, a health resort. Anne, who has never made a decision for herself in all of her life, let alone her mother, must make many choices in a town where she knows no one. On her own she begins to depend on herself and discover her own capabilities, writing to her cousin Mr. Darcy for assistance, choosing to stop taking the medicine that is making her so ill and meeting a local family the Caldwell’s who were friends of her deceased father many years ago. Amazingly, she is gaining her appetite, building her strength, and enjoying walks – something she has never been able to do all her life. When her cousins Miss Georgiana and Mr. Darcy arrive at Burley to take Lady Catherine and Anne to Pemberley, it is only Anne who departs after her mother’s insistence upon staying under the pretext of dutiful care. In actuality, she prefers the prospect of meeting the Duchess of Stilbury due for the social season over the former Miss Bennet the new Mistress of Pemberley.

Anne travels to Pemberley, and under the care of her cousins discovers that life away from the tyranny of her mother is a whole new world, and, she likes it! Not only does her health improve, she discovers that she also has a source of income from her father’s will that her mother has manipulated away for years, and that her prospects for romance look promising with the Caldwell’s son Edmund, a young man with ambition, honor, and intelligence, but no title. Her life is happier than she could ever have imagined – until Lady Catherine has her share of the conversation and the other shoe drops.

With so many Pride and Prejudice sequels, retellings, and spinoffs focused on the relationship of characters Lizzy and Darcy, following a minor character like Anne De Bourgh was delightfully refreshing. Brocklehurst fully understands Austen’s original characters and respectfully advances the story with humor, surprise, and suspense. Anne De Bourgh may have been timid and pitiable in the original novel, but her makeover by Brocklehurst has given her more than a bit of the true Darcy spirit.

4 out of 5 Stars 

Darcy and Anne, by Judith Brocklehurst
Sourcebooks, Landmark (2009)
Trade paperback (190) pages
ISBN: 978-1402224386


Cover image courtesy of Sourcebooks © 2009; text Laurel Ann Nattress © 2009, Austenprose.com

6 thoughts on “Darcy and Anne, by Judith Brocklehurst – A Review

Add yours

  1. Great review, Laurel Ann! I definitely agree with you on this one — a refreshing, fun and different read. It was easy to identify with Anne’s plight, and I was rooting for her from the get-go! Beyond that, I loved getting glimpses of Elizabeth and Darcy’s married life, too. There was just enough to be very interesting without shifting the focus away from Anne. Definitely a worthy read! And thanks for the link, too :)


  2. Wonderful review, Laurel Ann! This one was one of my favorites this year. Short and very sweet :) Its a pity there will be no more by this wonderful author.


  3. Thanks for another great review, Laurel Ann! I hadn’t heard much about this book yet, so I really appreciated reading your impressions of it and getting a sense of the storyline. Certainly, the inner world of Anne De Bourgh is untapped literary territory (!!), and I can imagine it must’ve been fun getting to explore the author’s vision of it. :)


  4. Sounds great! I had a taste of Anne De Burgh as a more central character in a Carrie Bebris book ..Matters at Mansfield and loved her. Got to love a story that gives power to someone so oppressed. I’m surprised more hasn’t been written with her as the heroine. Perhaps she will be the next character to receive lots of attention – as Mary Bennett did.

    Thanks for the review Laurel Ann


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: