Lady Harriette: Fitzwilliam’s Heart and Soul (Pride and Prejudice Untold), by P. O. Dixon – A Review

Lady Harriette, by P. O. Dixon (2013)Starting with the third book in any series is certainly a challenge. One feels rather late to the party when one has missed out on major events and character development in two previous novels, so why would I attempt it? Add to the fact that they were Pride and Prejudice “what if” stories changing the plot of Jane Austen’s classic tale, and the problems intensify. What could possibly tempt me to move beyond my prejudices and give, Lady Harriette: Fitzwilliam’s Heart and Soul, a chance? The plot appeared to be focused on the married life of Colonel Fitzwilliam and his new bride Lady Harriet Middleton. His cousin Fitzwilliam Darcy is married to Elizabeth Bennet already too? What? No courtship? Where was this going? I was intrigued.  

The book’s description and first few chapters truly piqued my curiosity. Lady Harriette was a beautiful young heiress twelve years younger than her husband, Colonel Richard Fitzwilliam, the second son of an earl with no fortune. How had he snagged HER, and what did the families think of this misalliance? We learn that he was a rake with a long-standing history of dalliance. I wondered if he had married for love or for money? The elephant in the room was how he will he ever keep his privileged and spoiled bride happy? Pressure mounts on Fitzwilliam after he discovers the ancestral property is near bankruptcy. Trying to keep this startling fact from his wife and family, while he and Darcy attempt to catch the thief, seemed wise, but later backfires. Even close friends Elizabeth and Fitzwilliam Darcy, whose happy life at Pemberley appeared untouchable, are faced with a ghost from the past when a young woman working as a housemaid at the Fitzwilliam estate has a painful connection to both Darcy and Fitzwilliam. Why is she there? Blackmail, or the evil workings of a disgruntled relative? The possibilities for conflict were mounting with every chapter.

Only a creative and skilled writer could truly pull all of these conflicts and challenges together. Author P. O. Dixon, known for her Pride and Prejudice variations, succeeded triumphantly. I was amazed at how she began the story after the marriage of the Fitzwilliam’s and then proceeded to fill in the backstory quite seamlessly. Having not read the first two novels in the series I did not know if she was back peddling or showing off her storytelling skills. It mattered not. Either way, it resulted in a page-turning plot. There were times when I found myself at a loss when characters like Jane Bennet, elder sister of Elizabeth, were not married to whom Austen paired them off with, or other sisters like Lydia had died. For the benefit of readers who are not familiar with the new twists taken from Austen’s plot that had transpired in previous novels, an author’s forward or a character list in the back would have answered those nagging questions that left me hanging. The character development of Col. Fitzwilliam and Lady Harriette was quite absorbing. I was skeptical that she would truly change, or that he really loved her. I knew that I would like the Col. from the start, and did, but Lady Harriette was another matter. She was a spoiled, rich girl who I could not connect with and wondered why the Colonel loved her beyond her youth, beauty, and money. You will have to read the novel to find out if they have their happy-ever-after.

I listened to an audio recording of Lady Harriette: Fitzwilliam’s Heart and Soul, read by Pearl Hewitt. The fast-paced story lent itself to a theatrical reading enhanced by Hewitt’s characterizations. This is truly a romance novel with some steamy love scenes, so please take heed. You are forewarned and forearmed for a great read. I highly recommend it.

4 out of 5 Stars

Lady Harriette: Fitzwilliam’s Heart and Soul (Pride and Prejudice Untold), by P. O. Dixon (audio recording) read by Pearl Hewitt
Audible (2013)
Digital audio recording (6 hours and 13 minutes)

Cover image courtesy of P. O. Dixon © 2013; text Laurel Ann Nattress © 2014,

5 thoughts on “Lady Harriette: Fitzwilliam’s Heart and Soul (Pride and Prejudice Untold), by P. O. Dixon – A Review

Add yours

  1. I’ve read this one and I enjoyed it. I’d read the first two books as well, so I went into it with feeling towards the characters from the previous storylines. I actually really disliked Lady Harriette at the outset, but she grew on me quite a bit during this lighthearted story. My favourite book of the three is the first one, To Have His Cake (and Eat It Too)


  2. What a great and well-written review, Laurel Ann! Like Ceri, I did not care for Lady Harriette much before this book, but I loved her in this book and was excited to read more about her and Col. Fitzwilliam’s marriage. She is so plucky, and I love a heroine with spunk and moxy.


  3. What a welcome surprise! The best kind by far. Thanks so much for your insightful review of Lady Harriette, Laurel Ann. You’ve captured the essence of the story perfectly. I read your review with such pleasure! The story was my first NaNoWriMo project; thus, will forever hold a special place in my heart. In addition, your account of the audio book so aptly describes Pearl Hewitt’s marvelously enchanting narration. Fast-paced and engaging, it draws me in every time. I’m so glad you enjoyed the story!


  4. Great review! This was on my to read list after reading the first two, near the end of the second novel I started to warm to her so was intrigued to find there was a follow up to their marriage. This story sounds very interesting especially the part about a maid at Pemberley!! I must say both the Colonel and Darcy vexed me exceedingly in the first novel but I supposed it added to the appeal of the story as it was different. I’m looking forward to reading it now, thank you.


  5. Audio books! What a wonderful suggestion to work even more Jane Austen into my day! I’m off to the library to see if I can find the other two books in audio version, so I can start at the beginning.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: