Spinster sleuth Miss Marple returned to Masterpiece Mystery last Sunday with her sensible shoes and ingenious deductions in one of Agatha Christie’s venerable warhorses, The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side. What true classic mystery aficionado has not seen one of the movie adaptations of this wonderful 1962 book of the same name? It has been trotted out no less than two times prior to this new production showcased by former Miss Marple’s: Angela Lansbury and Joan Hickson. Now Julia McKenzie gets her chance to slip into the Marple mantle and solve a double murder at a grand manor house in her own village of St Mary Mead.
The locals are all aflutter when an American film actress Marina Gregg (Lindsay Duncan) takes up residence at Gossington Hall with her fifth husband, a dashing young English film director Jason Rudd (Nigel Harman) who has resurrected her waning career and the country estate formerly owned by Miss Marple’s friend Dolly Bantry (Joanna Lumley). A charity benefit hosted by the glamorous couple includes the press and all of the community but Miss Marple who must regretfully remain at home with a sprained ankle. During the party, the inquisitive Dolly Bantry observes local Marina Gregg fan Heather Badcock (Caroline Quinten) rambling on to her hostess about their meeting years earlier. Marina’s mysterious reaction to Heather’s recollection is to stare off into the distance in frozen shock? Dolly thinks it quite odd, but is later distracted by a more tragic event. Heather is dead and a poisoned daiquiri is suspected.
Dolly wastes no time in revealing all the details of the party to her friend later that afternoon. Miss Marple suspects murder and wonders if the cocktail was really meant for Marina but given to Heather by mistake? Dolly continues her report by equating Marina’s death-like daze to a Tennyson poem, “Out flew the web and floated wide – The mirror crack’d from side to side; “The curse is come upon me,” cried The Lady of Shalott.” As the investigation continues, Inspector Hewitt’s (Hugh Bonneville) suspect list lengthens as all the guests are interviewed. Is it Marina’s ex-husband the spiteful gossip columnist, her husband’s ex-girlfriend the jilted starlet or the suspicious young female photographer snapping shots of the guests at the party? It appears that many at the party have secret reasons to want Marina dead, including Marina herself.
It is easy to understand why The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side has been adapted so many times by movie producers. It is an intriguing story dripping with Hollywood glamor and colorful characters. In this instance, the campy screenplay by Kevin Elyot moves Chrisite’s characterizations and plot twists even further toward a farcical spoof of the mystery genre than written or previously filmed. Director Tom Shankland’s use of over-the-top melodrama through clips of Marina’s films and the Movietone-like newsreels poke fun at the era and set the tone for the entire film. Oddly, Miss Marple is sidelined with an injury early on so her friend Dolly becomes her eyes and ears. Watching actress Joanna Lumley as Dolly acting like a giddy school girl over the celebrity parade and snooping on her neighbors was the highlight for me. Lumley’s infectious energy and deadpan comedy is so well suited for this type of role reminding me that Julia McKenzie’s low key and flat Miss Marple has yet to grow on me. The next episode of Miss Marple is an encore presentation of A Pocket Full of Rye on June 6th.
Laurel Ann (Austenprose)
Virginia Claire
Christina B.
RegencyRomantic
Kimberly (Reflections of a Book Addict)
shelleydewees
Br. Paul Byrd, OP
Aia A. Hussein
Lucy Warriner
Lisa Galek
I’m curious, I do not remember that McEwan starred in an adaptation of this novel. I do remember both the one with Angela Lansbury and the one with the truest Miss Marple, Joan Hickson. In fact, at IMDB there are only listed the ones I remember and there is no reference to one at McEwan’s filmography file overthere either. So are you sure there has been 3 adaptations?
PS – I forgot to add, this is based on one of the novels where Miss Marple do actually appear. In fact of the 12 Marple novels, there only remains A Caribbean Mystery to be adapted since ITV began the production of this series (it includes the McEwan’s three seasons).
The Blue Geranium is based on one of the short-stories where Miss Marple also appears, but of this new season the other 2 new episodes are based on non-Marple novels.
The Secret of Chimneys belong to one of the less known detectives, Superintendent Battle (who is not mentioned in the cast of this new adaptation), and it has a sequel: The Seven Dials Mystery, which is my favourite Christie, so it makes me suspect ITV is going to mess with it in the future :(.
Cinthia, I do believe you are correct. McEwan did not do this Marple. My mistake. I will make the correction. Thanks.
I enjoyed this film and am starting to “warm” to Julia McKenzie’s portrayal of Miss Marple. The fourth series – and JM’s 1st – was a bit hit-or-miss for me, but that was in no small part due to the fact that I had grown so attached to Geraldine McEwan’s take on Miss M. that I really missed her. Of course, it took me a season to really appreciate McEwan’s take on the role too. I am really looking forward to when the next “new” episode returns on June 20th…I do so wish the next three weeks weren’t padded with re-runs.
[...] May 23 – Miss Marple: The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side – My recap & review [...]
[...] Read Laurel Ann’s review. [...]
[...] Read Laurel Ann’s review. [...]
[...] Read my recap & review of The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side [...]
[...] Read my review of Miss Marple: The Mirror Crack’d from Side to Side [...]