Masterpiece’s Oliver Twist Review: Darkness and Discordance Descend as Episode Two Fizzles

Gregor Fisher and Sarah Lancashire, Oliver Twist (2007)

Episode two of Masterpiece Classic’s Oliver Twist on PBS concluded last night with a dull thud. It also did not help that it was competing in the same time slot at the 81st Academy Awards ceremony, so viewers like me who taped Oliver watched it after an anti-climatic new and improved Oscars that also left me flat. In my previous comments on episode one, I mentioned that this new adaptation was very dark. I had meant it metaphorically. Now I mean literary. The cinematography was so lacking in light, that too fequently I could decipher little, missing much, and relying entirely on dialogue. The music also got on my nerves and was too discordant. So, we must retrench and try to say something interesting about the conclusion of this new adaptation of Oliver Twist, by focusing instead on a few performances.

Sarah Lancashire as Mrs. Corney, Oliver Twist (2007)

Even though the main story revolves around men, I found the women in this production so much more interesting.  Sarah Lancashire as Mrs. Corney was the standout of all the actors for me though she had less screen time than any of the male leads. Her interpretation of the callous and mercenary matron of Mudfog workhouse was right on pitch. Mrs. Corny is such a mercurial character calling forth a range of emotions from harpy to conniver that not every actress could pull it off as convincingly as Ms. Lancashire. Bravo.

Morven Christie as Rose, Oliver Twist (2007)

Also of merit was Morven Christie as beautiful and compassionate Rose, whose concern for Oliver even though others think he is just a con artist was not over dramatic or maudlin. She was most compelling in the scene when Edward pressures her into accepting his marriage proposal. Others may remember her performance as Jane Bingley in the recent miniseries Lost in Austen. Though she made a woefully doe eyed Jane, I appreciated her much more as the fiery Rose.

William Martin and Tom Hardy, Oliver (2007)

Of the male leads, Tom Hardy gave us a dementedly scary rendition of the cutthroat thief Bill Sikes that has yet to be matched on screen. His piercing looks said far more than any of Dickens riviting dialogue. Young William Miller was, well cute, but a bit too bland for my taste. My favorite male performance was by far Julian Rhind-Tutt as the conniving Edward/Monks whose simmering anger and hatred gave me chills. A compelling and talented actor, I have followed his career since the 1994 Madness of King George and hope one day to see him in a lead role. A versatile actor, I am convinced that he could play anything superbly from a romantic lead to a villain in contemporary or period fare.

Julian Rhind-Tutt as Edward/Monks in Oliver Twist (2007)

Next up for Masterpiece Classic’s The Tales of Charles Dickens is the encore presentation of David Copperfield (1999), staring Daniel Radcliffe (Harry Potter) as the young master Copperfield to be broadcast in March. Check you local listings for dates and times.

2 thoughts on “Masterpiece’s Oliver Twist Review: Darkness and Discordance Descend as Episode Two Fizzles

Add yours

  1. I thought Rose was a little TOO fiery; I understand that they wanted to make her a little less saintly, but they overcompensated. Her rant at dinner was way over the top.

    I agree with you about Sarah Lancashire. Brilliant!


  2. I have to say that PBS’s version of Oliver Twist was simply brilliant.

    I wrote a quick review of it in my blog as well.

    I’m a huge Masterpiece fan.


Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Website Built with

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: