Mansfield Park Revelation: I am Fanny Price! Are You?

Newby Hall, Yorkshire

In Defense of Fanny Price

Even after the conclusion of Mansfield Park Madness, I am still ruminating over the novel and the characters. In order to put them to rest, I must get one thing off my chest! My journey to understand the novel has lead me to several insights and one profound truth. 

At the end of chapter 46 when Fanny Price, her sister Susan and cousin Edmund Bertram are returning by carriage to Mansfield Park, Jane Austen gives us a beautiful description of the countryside from Fanny’s perspective. 

Fanny had been everywhere awake to the difference of the country since February; but when they entered the Park her perceptions and her pleasures were of the keenest sort. It was three months, full three months, since her quitting it, and the change was from winter to summer. Her eye fell everywhere on lawns and plantations of the freshest green; and the trees, though not fully clothed, were in that delightful state when farther beauty is known to be at hand, and when, while much is actually given to the sight, more yet remains for the imagination. Her enjoyment, however, was for herself alone. Edmund could not share it. She looked at him, but he was leaning back, sunk in a deeper gloom than ever, and with eyes closed, as if the view of cheerfulness oppressed him, and the lovely scenes of home must be shut out. 

At that exact moment in my re-reading of Mansfield Park, I had a startling epiphany — a Catherine Earnshaw moment (the heroine of Emily Bronte’s novel Wuthering Heights, — when she ruminates over all of hero Heathcliff’s faults, and then proclaims exuberantly, “I am Heathcliff“, relieved to finally understand herself and know her destiny). I too had my enlightening moment, discovering through Fanny’s eyes as she observes her environment, the people around her, and her feelings that — “I am Fanny Price!” 

Sylvestra Le Touzel as Fanny Price (1983)

Ok, I heard that collective “ick” over cyber-space. I know — no one wants to be like a heroine that others think so ill of, who is accused of being meek, bland, insipid, passive and, –gulp– a prig!  Heavy faults indeed, which I admit not wanting to be associated with either. However, are these faults fairly applied? Is Fanny Price really as intolerable as some accuse her of being?

Carolyn Farina as Audrey Roguet (Fanny Price), Metropolitan (1990)

Honestly, up until that moment in the novel my impression of Fanny Price had been influenced by the general opinion that she is Jane Austen’s meek and unexciting anti-heroine spawning disparity of opinion to the point of igniting “Fanny Wars” among her advocates and nay-sayers in the Jane Austen community. Amused and baffled by all the controversy, here, here, and here, I had just taken it all in, waiting for my chance to discover the truth, trying to stay objective and unaffected until I could make my own decision. 

Frances O’Connor as Fanny Price (1999)

By Chapter 46, I had been impressed with her sincerity, her kindness and her principles in the face of so much human folly surrounding her at Mansfield Park and at Portsmouth. When her mentor and only friend Edmund attempts to convince her to marry Henry Crawford, her reaction is so profound, so firm, so principled, so honorable that I am amazed that others can discredit her. Who indeed could find fault with such a lovely and virtuous woman who knows herself so acutely that she alone understands what will give her a  happy and fulfilling life? Are money and social position more important than principles and love? She thinks not, and I sense that is also the point Jane Austen wants us to discover and question.

Billie Piper as Fanny Price (2007) 

So, in defense of Fanny Price I present “The Fanny List“, representing some of her amiable qualities that she exhibits in the novel. 

Loyalty, honor, sincerity, attentiveness, virtuous, inquisitiveness, bookishness, quietness, reserved, modesty, kindness, consideration, perception, patience, understanding, and morality  

You might think that this is an impressive list of atributes for a heroine, let alone a real person. Please do not misunderstand me when I say “I am Fanny Price”! I proclaim only an affinity to her, not an exact replica. I can only aspire to attain such an exaulted position!

Further-more, when we analyze all of Jane Austen’s seven heroine’s; Elinor & Marianne Dashwood, Elizabeth Bennet, Fanny Price, Emma Woodhouse, Anne Elliot, and Catherine Morland,  they all exhibit many of the characteristics on this list. They are personal qualities that society values, and that many aspire to. In my opinion, in a head-to-head throw-down, Fanny Price beats them all, hands down!

Recently, I took an online quiz created by Kali at the Emma Adaptations website which asked “Which Jane Austen heroine are you?” Surprisingly, my result was tabulated as Elizabeth Bennet! Even though I admire the witty and sparkling heroine of Pride and Prejudice, I was astounded that I subliminally thought that our personalities were alike; quite the contrary! On further reflection, we all might admire and aspire to be Lizzy Bennet, — but in reality — we are Fanny Price. Not such a bad thing after all, — in my humble estimation!

*Header photo of the grounds of Newby Hall, Yorkshire where the movie Mansfield Park (2007) was filmed.

10 thoughts on “Mansfield Park Revelation: I am Fanny Price! Are You?

  1. I feel maybe a bit of the different I aspire to be like Fanny, but I can never really live up to her. The way I see it the only think Fanny is missing is some kind og selfesteem. At least in the beginning she’s thinking it to be completly natural to be told that she must always be the lowest and the last. The low selfesteem should not be confused with low selfconfidence, which she doesn not have, at least not as the book goes on. She might not say it out loud (because of her low selfesteem) but she knows that Maria and Henry is acting wrongly. By the end of the book Fannys selfesteem is growing (look at how she views Henrys attatchment to herself) and a highers selfesteem is all that Fanny is missing to be perfect. I want to be Fanny Price, but I’m not there yet.

    Like

  2. I feel that those quizzes are very misleading…in that it is easy to pick out what character they’re talking about. I know I took that same quiz and turned out to be Elizabeth, but probably just because I wanted to be. If I could take an unbiased quiz, I sometimes wonder who I would turn out to be like…

    After these past few weeks though, I have to say that I like Fanny and mansfield park much more, and I agree that it wouldn’t be such a bad thing to end up being her!

    Like

  3. I’m beginning to change my reading of Fanny’s character from one as ‘weak and timid’ (and sure, she starts out that way, but she’s a natrually shy child dragged from her home to a stranger’s hosue of luxury where she is always reminded of her lowly ‘poor cousin status… AND she has to deal with Aunt Norris!) as one who uses her silence as a source of power – wisdom, strength. She definitely grows thorughout the novel, and people seem to miss that she actually develops into a pretty complex character.

    Like

  4. Pingback: The Jane Austen Survey 2008 Results are Posted at JASNA « Austenprose

  5. I’m not entirely sure I understand why people don’t like Fanny (but I’ve only just discovered this Blog and the idea of an online community of Fans – so maybe that’s just me!) I’ve always rather liked her – to me, when I read Mansfeild Park the first time, (when I was about thirteen) she was the ultimate good girl – the character by whom all the others in the book were compared (and they were all found lacking – even Edmund) and I rather liked her. She was the underdog, quietly sitting by, helping when needed and holding in her heart, nothing but hope. Even now, I still like her for the exact same reasons. I suppose the only ‘bad’ thing that can be said about her is that she is ‘too good to be true’. Buit that still doesn’t put me off.

    Like

  6. I don’t agree with you completely. I really like Fanny, she is my favourite heroine out of all. Mansfield park was the book I couldn’t stop reading, because of Fanny. But i always think, we are rather Elizabeth Bennett, not Fanny Price. I think Fanny is so unique and so good, that there is noone like her, as Edmund thinks in the book, noone is good enough for her. And I want to be Fanny Price so badly.
    I like this article, thank you

    Like

  7. Pingback: Friend of Fanny: Austenprose « Mansfield Park

  8. I think Fanny Price is the most courageous of Jane Austen’s heroines. Remember that she defies Sir Thomas when he insists that she marry Henry Crawford. She has no allies, no defenders, and is totally dependent on his good will. Yet she defies him in that crucial moment, and remains true to her own beliefs and principles. She is definitely a complicated character, and it is only in that moment that we see she is not the passive dupe we took her for, but a woman of character.

    Like

  9. Pingback: What happened to Carolyn Farina? | Julian O'Dea

Please join in and have your share of the conversation!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.